What Does 'Under Review' Mean in Academic Publishing?

Learn the significance of 'under review' in the academic publication process and its implications for your manuscript.

396 views

Under review generally means that your paper has not been desk rejected and is currently being evaluated by peer reviewers. Desk rejection typically occurs before the review stage, during the initial screening by the journal editor. If your manuscript is under review, it implies that it has met the basic criteria and is now undergoing a more detailed appraisal.

FAQs & Answers

  1. What is the meaning of 'desk rejection'? Desk rejection occurs when a journal editor decides not to send a manuscript for peer review, usually due to not meeting basic submission criteria.
  2. How long does the peer review process take? The peer review process can vary but typically takes several weeks to a few months, depending on the journal and reviewer availability.
  3. What should I do if my paper is under review for too long? If your paper is under review for an extended period, consider contacting the journal for an update on its status.
  4. Can I submit my manuscript to another journal while it's under review? Generally, you should not submit to another journal while it's under review as it may violate publication ethics.

Watch More

If you're navigating the world of academic publishing, check out our related videos on manuscript submission tips and understanding the peer review process for more insights.

  1. Understanding the Meaning of 'Under Review' in Application Processes Learn what 'under review' truly means for your application status and what to expect next.
  2. Understanding the Meaning of 'Under Consideration' in Academic Publishing Learn what 'under consideration' means for your paper in academic publishing and its significance in the review process.
  3. Does 'Under Consideration' Mean 'Under Review'? Understanding the Difference Explore the nuances between 'under consideration' and 'under review'—two terms often used in evaluations.
  4. Understanding the Difference: Under Consideration vs. Under Review Learn the nuances between 'under consideration' and 'under review' in decision-making processes.
  5. What Does It Mean If Your Application is Under Review? Discover the implications of having your application under review and what to expect during this process.
  6. Understanding the 'Decision in Process After Under Review' Status Learn what 'decision in process after under review' really means for your application status.
  7. Understanding the Meaning of 'Under Consideration' in Research Papers Learn what 'under consideration' means in research paper submissions and its implications for authors.
  8. What Does 'Under Consideration' Mean in Job Applications? Understand what 'under consideration' means in your job application status.
  9. Understanding 'Under Consideration': Meaning and Implications Discover the meaning of 'under consideration' and its implications in decision-making processes.
  10. What Does 'Under Consideration' Mean for Academic Papers? Learn about the 'under consideration' status of your academic paper and what it entails during the review process.
  11. Understanding the 'Under Consideration' Process in Application Reviews Learn what the 'under consideration' process means for your application review.
  12. Understanding If 'Under Consideration' Is Positive or Negative Learn what 'under consideration' means and why it’s usually seen as a positive sign in decision-making.