What was the first Creepypasta?

Related questions

1. What does Sonic EXE stand for?
2. Who is older Mario or Luigi?
3. Did Michael Jackson make Sonic music?
4. Who drew Sonic the Hedgehog?
5. Is Tail a boy or girl?
6. What was the first 3d Sonic game?
7. Is Sonic going out of business?
8. How old is Sonic in Sonic Generations?
9. What was the first Nintendo game?
10. How old is Sonic in Sonic 06?

Tags

1. #creepypastas
2. #which
3. #caver
4. #possible
5. #paranormal
6. #known
7. #appear
8. #originated
9. #original
10. #dedicated
11. #board
12. #older
13. #4chan
14. #creepypasta